Make groups of 4 and proceed to the following tasks. Work independently, ask for the tutor's support yourself whenever necessary!
TASK 1 (10')
Below you can see a list of criteria suggested to evaluate any ELT material.
Use PEN AND PAPER. Organise the criteria into three categories:
- General view
- Teacher's view
- Student's view
Consider. Any aspects missing? Add your own ideas.
TASK 2 (20')
Browse the pile of texbooks available in the class. In the group, agree on one of them (use the whole SET if available!). Evaluate the textbook according to the listed criteria.
TASK 3 (10' or 2' each group)
Present your evaluation to the class. Focus on the main positives nad neagtives of the chosen material.
___________________________________
ELT material evaluation criteria
- approach +
methodology (gram.translational vs. communicative; covert vs. overt)
- attractivity: topics, heroes, comic strips…
- book
organisation (linear vs. cyclical) + structure
- corresponding
with the age
- cultural
setting
- enables
individual work
- L1 role
(instructions in Czech or English?)
- language
skills balance
- practical
issues: materials included in the set available (recordings, workbook, posters,
flashcards, videos, tests, interactive materials, online support...)
- price,
availability, date of publishing
- publisher (CZ-EN-Other)
- readability
(dyslexics)
- structure –
easy to navigate
- supporting
Ss’ creativity and independence (Projects)
- T’s book and
instructions for Ss’
- the amount of
grammar explanation
- the balance
between presentation and practice (1:10)
- visual
impression (decorative vs. useful)
- vocabulary
range